Distressed loans secured by commercial property often involve delinquent real estate taxes. Workout professionals should remain mindful of this possibility as they analyze their collateral and make decisions concerning the enforcement of the loan. Questions I’m frequently asked are whether the lender should pay the real estate taxes and, if so, when.
Prior procedure. Indiana law historically required the plaintiff/lender, assuming it was the winning bidder at the sheriff’s sale, to pay any delinquent real estate taxes immediately after the sale. In the case of a cash bidder (third party), taxes would be paid off the top or, in other words, the county treasurer got the first cut of the sale proceeds.
2011. In recent years, we noticed that some county sheriff’s offices started to require the plaintiff/lender to pay delinquent real estate taxes before the sale. This has now become a formal, statutory requirement by virtue of Ind. Code § 32-29-7-8.5 “Requirements for Payment of Property Taxes and Real Estate Costs Before Sheriff’s Sale.” The statute states, in pertinent part, that “the party that filed the praecipe for the sheriff’s sale shall pay . . . all delinquent property taxes, special assessments, penalties, and interest that are due and owing on the property on the date of the sheriff’s sale.” A failure to pay will result in the cancellation of the sale.
Policing the issue? Beginning in January 2011 in Marion County (Indianapolis), the Treasurer, in conjunction with the Sheriff, requires that a Tax Clearance Form (.pdf) be (a) completed by the party requesting the sale, (b) stamped by the Treasurer’s Office and (c) then submitted to the Sheriff’s Office with the written bid. The form must be stamped regardless of whether delinquent taxes were ever an issue. Lender’s counsel needs to complete the information at the top of the form (the date of the sheriff’s sale, file number, owner, address and parcel number), as well as the contact information at the bottom of the form. The Treasurer’s Office completes everything else. Note that one form needs to be completed for each parcel number (i.e. 4 parcels, 4 forms).
As I’ve said on this blog many times, please be sure to confer with the particular county sheriff’s office in advance because rules and procedures may vary by county. Perhaps other counties will follow Marion County’s lead in terms of documenting the status of the real estate taxes. For now, call ahead to see what is needed.
Timing. At last week’s Marion County sales, we were able to submit payment for delinquent property taxes and obtain the stamped clearance form on the same day. The better approach would be to allow yourself and your foreclosure counsel a few days before the sale to address the matter in case there are problems or the Treasurer’s Office is congested. Without the stamped form, the Sheriff will not hold the sale. It is my understanding that the Treasurer may set up an e-mail address so these forms can be submitted and completed via e-mail. I will provide more information as it becomes available.
Build into judgment. Since I.C. § 32-29-7-8.5 now requires real estate taxes to be satisfied before the sale, the amount of any delinquent real estate taxes that either have been or will be paid by the lender should be an item of damages identified in the judgment. Before the statutory change, borrowers theoretically could attack that damage figure as being speculative. Some borrowers claimed that, because the lender had not actually incurred the loss at the time of the entry of judgment, courts could not award the damages. Hypothetically, the borrower might later pay the taxes or a third-party buyer might pay the taxes. Now, because the foreclosing lender is compelled to advance the taxes, courts in turn should be compelled to include such losses in the calculation of damages.
Plan ahead. In the past, delinquent real estate taxes may have popped onto the lender’s radar in the days leading up to the sheriff’s sale. Now, that issue should be addressed at the time of the filing of a motion for default judgment, motion for summary judgment or trial. Lenders and their foreclosure counsel should make it their routine practice, when calculating the debt, to verify with the county treasurer the status of the real estate taxes generally and the amount of any delinquent real estate taxes specifically. (As an aside, delinquent taxes frequently are identified in a title commitment.)